Vicarious violence

Vicarious violence

What is vicarious violence?

Vicarious violence is violence directed at sons and daughters in order to hurt their mother. The term was coined by the psychologist Sonia Vaccaro. It does not start with the children: it is usually a continuation of violence against the woman —coercive control, psychological and physical violence, harassment and stalking— when she tries to leave the relationship. The abuser then uses the children as a tool to keep controlling and hurting the mother, for example through contact arrangements, repeated court proceedings or the custody dispute. Irena suffered exactly this kind of violence before she lost her daughters. Catalonia was the first to recognise vicarious violence in law.

From violence against the woman to violence through the children

⛓

Coercive control

Monitoring where the mother is and who she is with, through constant calls and video calls; checking her phone; isolating her from her family and friends. Economic abuse: controlling the money and preventing her from working or having her own income.

💬

Psychological violence

Humiliation, insults, threats to take the children away from her or to harm them. Neglect of and aggression towards the children.

✋

Physical violence and harassment

Pushing, hitting, harassment, intimidation: varied and systematic acts of violence.

⚖

Children as a tool

When she leaves: contact arrangements, repeated court proceedings, the custody dispute.

💔

Emotional blackmail and a narrative against the mother

Pressuring the children with emotional blackmail and a story that blames their mother, so that they break their bond with her and reject her.

⚠

Extreme case: rejecting the mother to survive

In extreme cases, out of fear and survival instinct, children end up rejecting the mother they are not allowed to be with, under the pressure, aggression and emotional blackmail of the parent who has them in his care. Having to reject their own mother in order to survive is devastating for their mental health and has serious consequences throughout their lives. Research: E. Katz, Child Abuse Review (2016) →

⚠

Extreme case: murder

In its most extreme form, men take their children’s lives. According to Spain’s Ministry of Equality, between 2013 and March 2026 violent fathers murdered 68 children in Spain. Source →

Vicarious violence: what the law says in Catalonia and Spain

Law 17/2020 — legal definition

It amended Catalan Law 5/2008 on women’s right to eradicate male violence and added new forms of violence, including vicarious violence: any male violence against children or other people close to the woman with the aim of hurting her.

Decree-Law 26/2021 — Catalan Civil Code

Since 2010 the Catalan Civil Code has excluded from custody a parent with a final conviction or with well-founded indications of family or gender-based violence (art. 233-11.3). Decree-Law 26/2021 strengthened the rule: where there are indications of violence, no custody is granted and there are no stays or visits (arts. 233-11 and 236-5). The law exists. The problem is that it is not always applied.

LOPIVI — child protection

Organic Law 8/2021 extended the 2004 Gender Violence Act (art. 1.4) to include violence against children intended to hurt their mother, and recognised children’s right to be heard.

How research and the law have advanced

2010

The Catalan Civil Code establishes that custody of the children is not granted to a parent against whom there are well-founded indications of violence.

2017

The Spanish Parliament approves the State Pact against Gender Violence.

2020

Catalonia becomes the first to define vicarious violence in law (Law 17/2020). The first Barnahus for child victims of sexual violence opens in Tarragona, where children tell what they have been through only once and only to specialised professionals.

2021

In June the LOPIVI, Spain’s national law protecting children from violence, comes into force, and in November Catalonia passes Decree-Law 26/2021 on vicarious violence, which tightens the rules on custody and contact.

2023

The UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women, Reem Alsalem, finds in her report A/HRC/53/36 that family courts ignore violence in custody decisions. Catalonia already has 14 Barnahus centres.

2026

The Government sends Parliament a specific law on vicarious violence. With the early election, the bill lapses and remains pending.

Irena is not the first mother fighting to protect her children

In Spain, many mothers who reported violence and asked for their children to be protected ended up losing custody or were convicted for trying to protect them. Some well-known cases:

Irune Costumero (Biscay) — social services took her daughter away from her. In 2020 UN rapporteurs asked the Spanish Government for explanations, and four officials were brought to trial. Público · UN (2020)

Juana Rivas (Granada) — convicted of child abduction after reporting abuse, and stripped of parental authority. Her sons paid the highest price: in July 2025 the younger boy was handed over to his father in Italy, even though his psychologist warned that she feared for his life, and without the Spanish courts hearing the boy. The father is on trial in Italy for alleged physical and psychological abuse of both sons, and the mother has not been able to speak to her son since. Artículo 14 · El Salto

María Sevilla (Madrid) — convicted of abduction after reporting that her son described being abused; later partially pardoned. El Salto (2022) · El Salto (2023) · Público

Jewel Lázaro (Barcelona) — an American from Seattle; her daughter’s father is from Ireland, where the girl was born. In 2020, after an episode of family violence, she left with her daughter. In 2023 a Barcelona court sentenced her for child abduction to three years and one day in prison and seven years’ disqualification from parental authority; in March 2025 the Barcelona Provincial Court upheld the sentence. Jewel has applied for a pardon, arguing that she was protecting her daughter from abuse. El Salto · elDiario.es

A foreign mother (El Salto, 2025) — after asking for protection in Spain without success, she travelled with her daughter to her home country. Under the Hague Convention, the girl was taken from her and returned to Spain, and the mother was tried for child abduction. According to a Complutense University study for the Ministry of Equality, in 78% of the cases analysed the father obtained sole or shared custody at some point. El Salto (15/06/2025)

Other mothers whose cases have been reported in the press: María Salmerón (Seville) · Ana María Bayo (Madrid) · Sara B. (Extremadura) · Susana Guerrero · and many more

~400

documented cases

Networks of protective mothers have documented almost 400 cases. When the same pattern repeats so many times, the problem is not each individual mother: it is that the law, or the way it is applied, fails to meet an essential need — protecting children by listening to them. The reform of the LOPIVI and the vicarious violence law are still pending.

More cases of protective mothers: El Salto — Madres protectoras

Being a foreigner should not count against you. But it does.

Studies show that migrant mothers face additional obstacles in the justice system and in protection services:

The Observatory of Institutional Male Violence (OVIM) analysed 139 cases in its 2026 report: six out of ten point to the judicial sector, in 94% the institutions’ actions re-victimised the woman, and this violence is more common among migrant women.

According to migrant mothers’ groups, 62.6% of cases of institutional violence have a racist basis, and records of suspected child abuse take into account factors such as the mother being a foreigner or her command of the language.

GREVIO (Council of Europe) noted in 2024 that migrant women are over-represented among victims of gender-based violence in Spain and called for mandatory training for judges who decide on custody and contact.

A 2025 report on the VioGén system concludes that migrant women suffer more victimisation and receive less protection, because the risk assessment does not take their situation into account.

A foreign mother with no family in the country who reports a Spanish citizen with a good social position starts at a disadvantage. We ask that Irena’s case be handled with equal treatment and free from prejudice, as required by art. 4.3 of the Istanbul Convention and art. 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

International law

Spain is bound by UN and Council of Europe conventions and by European Union law. These rules protect both mothers and children.

International (UN)

Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989)

arts. 3, 9, 12, 19

Best interests of the child (3); not separating a child from a parent unless their interests require it (9); right to be heard (12); protection from all forms of physical or mental violence (19).

Committee on the Rights of the Child — General Comments 12, 13 and 14

How to guarantee the child’s right to be heard (GC 12), to be free from violence (GC 13) and to have their best interests come first (GC 14).

CEDAW (1979) and General Recommendation 35 (2017)

arts. 2, 5, 16.1.d

Obligation to eliminate discrimination and gender stereotypes, including in the courts (2, 5); equality in family relations, with the children’s interests as the paramount consideration (16). The CEDAW Committee already found against Spain in 2014 (communication 47/2012) for failing to take violence into account when setting contact arrangements.

UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women — report A/HRC/53/36 (2023)

UN report on custody, violence against women and violence against children, 13/04/2023

It shows that family courts ignore domestic violence in custody decisions. Special Rapporteur Reem Alsalem calls “parental alienation” a pseudo-concept and describes how abusers use it in family courts to discredit reports of violence. Report (PDF, UN) →

Europe

Istanbul Convention (Council of Europe, 2011; Spain, 2014)

arts. 4.3, 26, 31, 33, 34, 35, 48, 56

No discrimination, including on the grounds of origin or migrant status (4.3); protection of children exposed to violence (26); incidents of violence must be taken into account in custody and contact, without endangering the mother or the children (31); psychological violence (33), stalking (34) and physical violence (35); ban on mandatory mediation (48); protection of victims during proceedings (56).

European Convention on Human Rights

arts. 3, 8, 14

Prohibition of inhuman or degrading treatment (3), right to family life (8) and freedom from discrimination (14). The ECtHR has ruled against states for failing to protect women who reported violence (Opuz v. Turkey, 2009; Talpis v. Italy, 2017).

EU Charter of Fundamental Rights

art. 24

Children have the right to protection, to express their views freely and to have their best interests come first.

Directive 2012/29/EU (victims) and Directive (EU) 2024/1385 (violence against women)

Individual assessment of protection needs, with children presumed to be particularly vulnerable; the 2024 directive strengthens protection for victims of gender-based violence and their children.

Lanzarote Convention (Council of Europe, 2007)

art. 35

Interviews with children who may be victims of abuse must take place without delay, in suitable premises, by trained professionals and as few times as possible.

Scientific research

Academic publications and reports describing how family courts treat mothers who report violence against themselves and their children.

Débora Ávila, Adela Franzé, M.ª Carmen Peñaranda, Marta Pérez (Complutense University of Madrid), Patricia González Prado (Antígona Group, Autonomous University of Barcelona)

Violencia institucional contra las madres y la infancia. Aplicación del falso síndrome de alienación parental en España

Spanish Ministry of Equality, Government Delegation against Gender Violence

Analyses 47 cases and 63 criminal judgments. In 78% of the cases the father obtained sole or shared custody at some point, and in 65% the mother lost custody to the father.

Report (PDF) →

Joan S. Meier (George Washington University)

U.S. child custody outcomes in cases involving parental alienation and abuse allegations: what do the data show?

Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 42(1), 2020, pp. 92–105

A study of 10 years of US court decisions: a mother reporting abuse increases her risk of losing custody, and a counter-claim of “alienation” by the father almost doubles it.

DOI →

Mairead McCormack (Queen’s University Belfast)

Endless litigation in family court as a method of post-separation coercive control

Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law, 2025

How abusers use never-ending court proceedings to maintain coercive control after separation, and how mothers’ protective actions are interpreted as “hostility”.

Publication →

Jezabel Lucas García, Concepción Unanue Cuesta, M.ª Jesús Irurtia Muñiz (University of Valladolid)

Article on making vicarious violence visible in professional practice

Investigaciones Feministas (Complutense University of Madrid)

Describes the characteristics of vicarious violence, the warning signs and how professionals perceive it.

PDF →

Adrienne Barnett (Brunel University London)

Domestic abuse and private law children cases: a literature review

Ministry of Justice (United Kingdom), 2020

A review of research on the risks to children and mothers in custody and contact proceedings where there is violence in the family.

Report (PDF) →

Need help?

016 · Support for victims of gender-based violence (Spain), free, 24 h
900 900 120 · Helpline against gender-based violence (Catalonia), free, 24 h
116 111 · Infància Respon (Catalonia), if a child is at risk
112 · Emergencies

Estamos con Irena

#EstamosConIrena

We do not publish the girls’ names, images or any details about them. Please do not share them.

Legal notice · Privacy and cookie policy · Contact